BBC Disability Ministry
We exist to spread a passion for the supremacy of God in all things for the joy of all peoples through Jesus Christ.We joyfully live with a hard and glorious truth: God purposes disability in his creation for his glory and for our good.
BBC Disability Ministry Blog » When 'Composite' Means Self-Deception or Deception
43 Comments- Add comment | Back to Home Written on 11-Sep-2009 by john.knightsrTom Shakespear, writing in his article "Arguing about Genetics and Disability" in the book Theology, Disability and the New Genetics, makes the classic academic move to appear objective. He is writing a dialogue between two 'sides' of an argument, and ends his introduction this way:
The author's own views are a composite of both characters' positions. (p. 67)
My antenna immediately go up on statements like that. I worked on a college campus for nine years and learned that many faculty of the highest credentials live with fear of looking foolish before their colleagues. Thus, some will argue over the smallest matter of definition or school of thought, becoming very skilled at cleverness and subtlety, and will never fully reveal what they believe about something.
So, what am I to believe about this 'composite' of two positions?
Self-deception appears to be the main problem, particularly if he believes he is being objective in creating an argument. His dialogue quickly shows us where stands on a core moral issue that is central to the 'argument.' However, both of his characters agree on that moral issue. Agreement means there is no substantive argument actually taking place.
And if he knows what he is doing, that his dialogue really is just a nuanced conversation in support of a controversial (and I would add, horrendous) moral positioning and not an argument at all, than his above statement about a 'composite' is dishonest.
I am not arguing that he can't create his dialogue between two different sides of an argument. Using such literary devices serves a useful purpose and can be very helpful. I have also been watching different authors engage each other, such as Pastor John's The Future of Justification: A Response to N.T. Wright. Pastor John clearly disagrees with N.T. Wright, but attempts to present Bishop Wright's arguments fairly. Some have argued he didn't understand Wright completely - but at least we know what he believes and why he has engaged Bishop Wright. I would suggest that this type of engagement is a much higher statement of respect for Bishop Wright than trying to play both sides to appear smart.
This notion - of living in nuance and subtlety, being able to illuminate on a subject without revealing where one stands, playing on the edges of two sides of an argument - is a powerful incentive to place intellectual engagement above righteousness and what God has to say about a subject. And it leads to sin.
After all, we are not called to be clever, but to place our trust in Jesus and be called by the world as foolish.
And when the subject is as serious as abortion and pre-natal screening, which is the point of the 'argument', disabled babies are placed in the cross-hairs for termination, no matter how one side argues against pre-natal screening. It is, after all, just another morally acceptable choice; the two sides have already agreed on that.
Please, don't play games like this. That choice is not morally acceptable. Reveal what you believe, no matter the cost, especially when real babies are being aborted because of disability. The arguments should be just as stark and final as the termination of a pregnancy.
Send to a friend Comments
(@64x64C).jpg)
written on 06-Jul-2010
ed hardy [http://www.mycheapedhardy.com] says:
We'r ed hardy outlet one of the most profession of the coolest and latest ed hardy apparel, such as ed hardy tee ,ed hardy bags, ed hardy bathing suits, ed hardy shoes, ed hardy board shorts ，ed hardy watches women,ed hardy jeans for women ed hardy swimwearand more, ed hardy clothing. We offers a wide selection of fashion cheap ed hardyproducts. Welcome to our shop or just enjoy browsing through our stunning collection available wholesale ed hardy in our shop.
written on 06-Aug-2010
Fry26CHARITY [http://www.manyessays.com] says:
I probably must come along your good theme just about this good topic in the term paper and just music and movies essays finishing. Hence, thanks for your stuff.
written on 07-Aug-2010
gansiwei [http://www.highreplica1.com] says:
Providers in many luxury brands, we have our own unique advantages, high-quality selection, the perfect lathe to produce the Replica Handbags and Louis Vuitton are recognized by users around the world. One of our Louis Vuitton Handbags are unique in many brands, Wholesale Louis Vuitton Handbags to the world in more than 80 countries and regions, Wholesale Replica Handbags by European and U.S. customers welcome, we have a convenient logistics channel, the real customers reduce the cost. Louis Vuitton world's leading luxury brand, has the largest number of fans, including their Louis Vuitton Handbags more popular in the world, we mainly offer Louis Vuitton Replica Handbags, through our technology to achieve the same level of quality and true . Why are Replica Handbags and Designer Handbags so popular then, is that in real package is too expensive, and most people 815GanSiwei can not afford, so they can Wholesale Louis Vuitton Handbags and people want to keep the change package, so there is cheap Replica Handbags, while in replica handbags being, Louis Vuitton and Louis Vuitton Handbags are the best in Designer Replica Handbags for sale, as Louis Vuitton Handbags in the world with the most luxury one package, if you need Wholesale Louis Vuitton Handbags, they can contact us,Thank you!
written on 23-Aug-2010
Reebok Shoes [http://www.discounteasytone.com] says:
Reebok Zigtech Shoe is unique, dramatic for the multi-surface outsole. Zig Pulse is designed to conserve energy and return it to you. Reebok shoes on sale.
written on 23-Aug-2010
reebok easytone [http://www.easytoneshoes-sale.com] says:
reebok easytone shoes create natural instability. reebok easy tone increases muscle activity. discount easy tone will be available.
written on 24-Aug-2010
plush blankets [http://www.budgetblankets.com/] says:
Hey this is a great post. Custom Blankets,I’m going to email this to my buddies.Fleece Blankets,I will return to check on upcoming articles thanks for sharing.Plush Blankets,I would be extremely interested to hear more information on this.Embroidered Blankets, Cheers!Amiable dispatch and this mail helped me alot in my college assignement.fleece throw,Just want to say what a great blog you got here! Say thank you you on your information.Keep posting stuff like this i really like it.
written on 03-Sep-2010
NFL Jerseys Wholesale [http://www.nfljerseystoday.com/] says:
NFL Jerseys Wholesale NFL Jerseys Authentic GHD Straighteners
written on 13-Nov-2010
monclerlife [http://www.monclerlife.com] says:
This continuous drought has led the amazon river flows through a Peruvian than in 2005, Moncler jackets down to the water below the lowest in 40 years, this means for decades the amazon rainforest in South America will has long been moncler jackets moncler coats devastating drought in the most severe threat, the drought. The scientists from Peru and Brazil, moncler sale said during the annual monsoon season now becomes very typical of the rainfall in rainy season, but should be early rain lasts a few weeks. Moncler With a view of such drought will continue, because the Atlantic hurricane absorption of severe form of the amazon region took a vapor. Moncler jackets sale Guardiola admit need careful, especially recently spoke about real Madrid and dingyi topic. Help the media, but the repeated the Barcelona coach can only be serious, I don’t want to say any words mourinho said coach how transfers-will have their own ideas, Moncler jackets Men I respect each player, fans, they will understand you is sent first or substitute intention, coach impossible everybody. Although Barcelona in moncler strength, moncler jackets women but start in la liga is obvious, mourinho was worried about other teams will give barca gave for the title this season, he had to act as a provocation to la liga ZhuDui alarming. Guardiola is also capable of this point, so in this sensitive, moncler jackets women black he didn’t want to concentrate on unnecessary waste build-up.
written on 08-Apr-2011
Marc Jacobs Handbag [http://www.etohandbag.com/marc-jacobs-handbag-c-158.html] says:
Marc Jacobs handbag Improves Your Personal Style, The latest trends in the world of fashion have proven. Marc Jacobs' brand constant pursuit of quality and true fashion, and successfully join the New York's power and Paris'luxury together, so that Discount Marc Jacobs Handbag has a casual style of aristocratic!
written on 08-Apr-2011
Thomas Wylde Bags [http://www.tradebuybag.com/thomas-wylde-bags-c-169.html] says:
As one of the most popular designer bags brand in the world, Thomas Wylde handbags are characterized by different individual styles and its skull head has increased several mischievous breaths for young people. The skull (the brand mark) appeals on each model of Thomas Wylde handbags. These designs are rather new, fashionable, and well worth collection.
written on 19-May-2011
jordan shoes [http://www.airsneakershop.com] says:
Its useful for us .i hope you can keep sharing such interesting things to us
written on 02-Jun-2011
Supra Shoes [http://www.suprashoes-canada.ca/] says:
think about it
written on 18-Jul-2011
china jerseys [http://www.chinajerseys.org] says:
It really is indeed amazing to study your report. Boston Bruins JerseyI enjoy your style.interesting info indeed!
written on 18-Aug-2011
wow gold says:
http://www.topmmogoldz.com wow gold
written on 18-Aug-2011
replica handbags [http://www.cheappursesbiz.com/] says:
replica handbags
There is actually some good points on this blog some of my readers may find this useful http://www.cheappursesbiz.com/written on 18-Aug-2011
MBT [http://www.mbtcalzature-outlet.com/] says:
It is very good ! http://www.mbtcalzature-outlet.com/
written on 18-Aug-2011
cheap air max [http://www.cheapairmax.us/] says:
I like this site it have great images of dining tables and have a great work i like this images http://www.cheapairmax.us/
written on 04-Sep-2011
loan [http://www.bestfinance-blog.com] says:
Following my own exploration, millions of persons all over the world get the mortgage loans at various banks. Thence, there is a good possibility to get a financial loan in any country.
written on 24-Sep-2011
cheap nfl jerseys [http://www.cheapjerseysbestseller.com/] says:
Very happy to see your article, I very much to like and agree with your point of view.
written on 28-Sep-2011
cheap clothes online [http://www.cheapmass.com] says:
It makes me feel so surprise.I never know there is such a place that I can find cheap designer clothing,The site offers different designer clothing wholesale kinds of LV,Chanel,Coach etc.It's really a great clothes stores with cheap and high quality.Join it now!
written on 28-Sep-2011
ken griff shoes [http://www.cheap-griffeys.com] says:
This article is impressive,I hope that you will continue doing nice article like this.And do you like ken griff shoes,I have collected many beautiful griff shoes these years, the griff are so popular, I think you also can shop one ken griff shoes online store.
written on 10-Oct-2011
UGGS Classic Short [http://www.uggsclassicboots.org/] says:
I like your blog, hope you have more exciting content.
written on 12-Oct-2011
Evering2010 [http://www.cheapuggboots2012.com] says:
Thank you for sharing them with us , I think it's worth reading
written on 17-Oct-2011
cheap christian louboutin [http://www.christianoutletstore.net] says:
I recently necessary some good information in addition to appeared to be looking for Search engines because of it. My spouse and I went to each individual web site the fact that emerged about to begin with site in addition to would not obtained just about any appropriate consequence webpage for myself regarded as browse the following one particular along with your blog post. This is just what I need to!
written on 19-Oct-2011
canada goose parka [http://www.canadagoose2011parka.org] says:
It’s worth to read it.Thank you for sharing.canada goose parka will bring you a happy and free life when you are outside for skiing or playing. canada goose are all in good quality, and the price of them is cheap and worthy for you to buy. canada goose jackets sale online in 2011 owns many different designs and materials, you can come and choose. http://www.canadagoose2011parka.org
written on 20-Oct-2011
Ugg boots sale [http://www.uggbootssalecheap.com/] says:
YY7RYNP0ZMWSYY
For winter you can probably get terrific very broad variety of friends and females shoes.written on 22-Oct-2011
casque dr dre [http://www.beatsbydre-france.fr] says:
individuals would regard many of these Classic Cardy Boots On Purchase as unfashionable or uncool mainly
written on 25-Oct-2011
UGG Classic Cardy says:
http://www.loveuggbootsale.co.uk/These UGG Classic Cardy are a dream! They are extremely comfortable and very stylish too. Great with leggings and for sore, pregnant feet!I love these UGG Classic Cardy Boots. They are warm and super comfy! They are a bit larger than the leather UGG Classic Cardy Sale but once you put socks on they feel much better. They look great folded down and also slouched as well. I get tons of compliments on them. I want them in every color!
written on 31-Oct-2011
Moncler Jackets Sale [http://www.cheapmonclerbase.com] says:
moncler jacket is better item i just pick up because of your ex boyfriend through wintry weather. Femal can't look chilled through wintry weather, whenever you would definitely turned out to be out of date fast for everybody who is chilled. Which means your ex boyfriend would definitely pay for moncler jackt, dress, vest out of your moncler jacket retailer on sale stow in my circumstances. I just still find it the right gift items in my circumstances. Look very happy!
written on 31-Oct-2011
Moncler Jackets outlet [http://www.cheapmonclerbase.com] says:
While Moncler spencer
Having moncler, moncler I do think consequently lighting
along with wonderful. I think similar to wandering with your beach front, cozy breeze wasting upon
our knowledge. Air can be so stimulating, along with most puts a stop to, making merely me as well as
orange atmosphere. What"s further, I can certainly not allow referfing to a advantage "" performance.written on 03-Nov-2011
cheap moncler [http://www.monclerworthy.com] says:
It seems as though our spam filter has detected what looks to it like spam. But Don't Panic - the post has definitely been saved.
If this is an error, please use the 'Report an Issue' link at the bottom of the page to contact our Customer Support team. Advise the name and url of your site and the related blog, and that you received this anti-spam message and we can override the spam-score to publish your post (usually by the next working day).written on 05-Nov-2011
ugg classic short [http://www.classicalboots.org/] says:
F62V5YKDWK5FJT8
written on 05-Nov-2011
ugg classic short [http://www.classicalboots.org/] says:
F62V5YKDWK5FJT8written on 05-Nov-2011
ugg boots clearance [http://www.cheap-uggs-boots-sale.co.uk/] says:
HWZOU44G01YFMKPWT
only made with australian twin-face sheepskin are authentic ugg bootswritten on 11-Nov-2011
cheap nike shoes [http://www.newairmaxsite.com/] says:
A man may lead a horse to the water, but he cannot make it drink.
written on 12-Nov-2011
supra shoes [http://www.supraskytopshoe.com/] says:
http://www.supraskytopshoe.com/
By 1976 over the eighties, this Traditional fashi http://www.supraskytopshoe.com/
onable music group accumulatedwritten on 14-Nov-2011
UGGs Cheap [http://www.winterbootsale.co.uk/] says:
This site is very interesting and also great. I'm glad to find out this ste immediately. It's very informative.
written on 28-Nov-2011
x22 irons [http://www.cheapbestgolf.com/cheap-Callaway-X-22-Left-Irons-wholesale_885.html] says:
I'm glad to be here to see these information!!!!!!
written on 21-Dec-2011
Callaway Diablo Octane Tour Fairway [http://www.golfwholesalemart.com/cheap-Callaway-Diablo-Octane-Tour-Fairway-Wood-for-sale_1188.html] says:
I'm glad to be here to see you information
written on 21-Dec-2011
Callaway Diablo Octane Tour Fairway [http://www.golfwholesalemart.com/cheap-Callaway-Diablo-Octane-Tour-Fairway-Wood-for-sale_1188.html] says:
I'm glad to be here to see you information
written on 07-Jan-2012
best golf clubs [http://www.cheapbestgolf.com/] says:
Is some good information, I really like here
written on 16-Jan-2012
maomao12 [http://www.cheapbestgolf.com/] says:
I'm very excited to come here, thank you for the article
written on 07-Mar-2012
cheap handbags outlet [http://www.sac-de-luxes.com] says:
Good work，it is a unique site and it is very interesting, i am looking forward for more updates.
Leave a Comment
- Server: web2.webjam.com
- Total queries:
- Serialization time: 4204ms
- Execution time: 4860ms
- XSLT time: $$$XSLT$$$ms